VSNL's big bet
Business World
— December 13, 2004
The market seems to be pleased with VSNL. Though it may still
not be looked upon as one of the favourite telecom companies,
investors are waking up to the fact that it has potential.
According to analysts, bandwidth requirements in Asia-Pacific
and India are expected to grow and this will augur well for
VSNL, which announced a deal by Tyco, one of the three big
global players in undersea cables, last month.
The VSNL stock has moved up around 38 per cent year-to-date to
current levels of Rs 227. However, it does not look too cheap
if one considers FY05 or FY06 earnings estimates. But
investors who are ready to hold on for a longer timeframe -
three-four years - may reap the benefits of the company's new
strategic initiatives.
The right moves
Ever since VSNL's monopoly in international telephony ended a
few years ago, it had to seek revenues from other businesses.
Its recent entry into the data service business augurs well in
this regard. "Data services is the big story in telecom
worldwide and VSNL needs to join the big league," says an
analyst. This is where the company's takeover of Tyco Global
Network (TGN) for $130 million fits in.
The deal will make VSNL one of the top three undersea-capacity
businesses globally along with Global Crossing and Reliance
Infocomm (which bought Flag Telecom in January 2004). With the
Tyco takeover, VSNL now owns a huge global network of undersea
cables. Tyco's trans-Atlantic, trans-Pacific network spans
60,000 km and crosses Europe. It has one of the largest
capacities globally which can transfer data at the rate of
seven terabits per second (1,000 gigabits make a terabit).
Growth is expected to arise from the trans-Pacific network
where TGN's strength lies - around 44 per cent of its capacity
is situated in the Pacific route where there is less traffic
currently. As for the trans-Atlantic section, where there is
already a lot of traffic, it will be a source of steady
revenues, feel analysts. Tyco's network happens to be fairly
new (three years old) and one of most expensive ones.
According to estimates, Tyco would have spent around $3
billion in building its network, while the figures for the
other leaders, Global Crossing and Flag Telecom, would have
come to $750 million and $1.1 billion respectively. VSNL paid
$130 million to acquire the Tyco network, which is lower than
what Reliance Infocomm paid to acquire Flag Telecom ($210
million). But analysts estimate that VSNL will have to put in
a considerable amount (at least as much as the cost of
acquisition) to get the whole thing started, including
lighting the unlit portion of Tyco's network that links Japan
to Singapore.
VSNL's first self-owned undersea cable (spanning 3,175 km with
5.12 terabits of capacity), linking Chennai to Singapore, has
been completed, adding to its bandwidth capacity. The Tyco
deal complements this process by helping the company increase
its presence in the region between Singapore and the US. The
company has also signed a Rs 500-crore deal with Cisco Systems
for broadband connectivity to provide data services in the
domestic market. It intends to spend about Rs 1,000 crore in
the next two years on broadband in the local market.
"We can expect the new deals to generate revenues after
two-three years," says a telecom analyst from a leading
domestic brokerage.
Demand on run
Such huge capacities will not be rendered useless if one looks
at the demand for bandwidth in the years to come. According to
Nasscom, bandwidth demand is expected grow over 50 per cent in
FY05 to 15.42 gbps (gigabits per second) from 10.23 gbps
currently. Demand is expected to double every year post-FY05.
The highest demand for bandwidth comes from the Internet
segment which is expected to grow over 100 per cent to 4.66
gbps in FY05. Such demand can catapult VSNL's position,
especially with the kind of capacity it has acquired.
International bandwidth prices in the Asia-Pacific region are
expected to fall by 20-25 per cent annually as there is
already excess capacity and players compete for data-driven
business, says a recent report by Gartner. With the SMW-4
cable - set up by a consortium of South-East Asian players to
connect India to the western and eastern regions of the globe
- there will be more capacity in the region, fuelling a
further decline in prices.
The moot point is whether the fall in prices will be offset by
growing volumes, considering the burgeoning demand. Currently,
a one mbps (megabits per second) link from Mumbai to Singapore
costs around $4,800 per month. VSNL stands to gain here once
it starts its operations on a global scale though it is
difficult to predict the kind of revenues this will generate.
Financials
VSNL's revenues have been slumping for the past few years due
to pricing pressures arising out of competition in the
international long-distance (ILD) telephony business. Net
profit dipped 30.5 per cent to Rs 88.1 crore in the second
quarter (Q2) of FY05 against the previous quarter. Operating
margins declined 630 basis points to 22 per cent. For FY04,
the company's profits declined 51.58 per cent to Rs 377.7
crore.
But VSNL has been diversifying its services, and segments
other than ILD accounted for 25 per cent (Rs 193.9 crore) of
revenues in Q2, compared to 23 per cent in Q1. It is
heartening that these services accounted for 45 per cent of
EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax and depreciation) in Q2,
compared to 41 per cent in Q1, and are expected to grow on a
linear scale going forward.
However, revenues from the ILD business have continued to fall
in Q2 (down 4 per cent to Rs 584.6 crore). But higher revenues
from other services have offset the decline in the ILD
business to an extent. TGN's financials remain a concern for
the company. A large portion of TGN's costs (about 80 per
cent, amounting to $115 million in FY03) is fixed, which could
nick VSNL's profits in the short-term.
"Though Tyco's operating losses could hit VSNL’s performance
now, the business potential ahead will make up for it," says
an analyst. Going forward, VSNL's marketing capabilities will
be put to test to bring in volumes for revenues. For FY03,
TGN's operating losses stood at $799.8 million.
Wait and watch
While it may too soon for analysts to give the green signal,
VSNL seems to hold potential for investors who are generally
willing to bet on the long-term potential of telecom data
services. The company is doing the right things, albeit a tad
late. It has the potential and qualifies as a long-term pick.
Most analysts expect the fall in earnings to continue at least
till FY05, with Tyco doing little for the bottomline.
"We expect an EPS of Rs 12.5 for FY05," says the head of
research at a leading domestic broking house. This translates
into a decline of 5.6 per cent against last year and a P/E of
15.6 times FY05 earnings (12-month trailing P/E stands at
14.8x).
|
|