Economic
Times - September 3, 2003
VSNL chairman Ratan
Tata today painted a very dismal picture of the company’s
future, warning shareholders that the international long
distance (ILD) business would be "gone" next year
when BSNL and MTNL start their ILD operations.
"A major source
of income will be gone. We need a new line of business or
other lines of businesses," said Mr Tata while answering
shareholders queries at the annual general meeting here today.
A plan for new businesses will be known by the end of this
year, he said. "Last year, we were just trying to keep
our head above water. I will be able to better describe our
roadmap at the time of the next financials."
At present, VSNL has
a 66% market share of the ILD business since BSNL/MTNL have to
route all international calls through VSNL till March ‘04.
"But this will be challenged, unless we find a way to
move forward," Mr Tata said. BSNL is expected to start
its own ILD operations after April next year. "The impact
of that needs to be fully digested," he added.
Mr Tata spoke about
the "instantaneous change of circumstances" after
July last year, when new rates and revenue-share agreements
were thrust upon the company. He asked shareholders — who
complained that the company was ‘sliding’ — to consider
the change in environment as they monitor VSNL’s
performance. He said one-two year period was too short and a
company should be judged over a longer period, especially the
new businesses.
N Srinath, director
(operations), seemed more optimistic as he felt that some sort
of customer access mechanism will be in place before BSNL/MTNL
get into ILD. Regarding new businesses, Mr Srinath said the
company had already taken several initiatives such as
corporate data services like IP VPN, MPLS, targeting new
geographies from the ILD standpoint. But he admitted that
these were not enough to substitute the ILD business.
"The corporate data business has increased, but even
there the tariffs are falling."
Tatas have engaged
Boston Consulting Group to help them in several areas like
controlling costs, profit enhancement programmes and specific
initiatives like bandwidth. The bandwidth business is one of
the new areas that VSNL will be focusing on. The company has a
37% share of the internet market and a 50% share of the
corporate data market.
VSNL has planned a
capex of Rs 1,200 crore for the current year, of which Rs 200
crore will be utilised to establish bandwidth capability and
Rs 245 crore for establishing the NLD network. Speaking at the
AGM today, Mr Tata said that a sum of Rs 600 crore will be
used for the undersea cable capacity, Rs 205 crore will be
invested in Tata Tele,
Rs 36 crore in voice circuits and Rs
150 crore would be used for other capex.
Responding to
queries, Mr Tata said they were waiting for government
clearances before they could use the line that ‘VSNL is a
Tata enterprise’. Regarding the balance holding of the
government, he said there had been some discussions from the
government’s side on the subject.
While speaking to
shareholders, Mr Tata said they had written to the government
asking for a review of the quantum of compensation for early
withdrawal of monopoly. He also said they were in discussions
with the government for sale/lease of the ILD infrastructure
to avoid duplication, after which the Tatas will outsource
their ILD operations. "These applications have neither
been accepted or rejected."
He also said that the
grey market operations in the ILD arena were resulting in
revenue loss of around Rs 500 crore.
Regarding the
turbulence in the telecom sector, Mr Tata said that the
schemes and discounts will disappear and the quality of
services will matter eventually. "Right now, it looks
terrible like vanaspati being sold between players, but soon
it will get hi-tech."
Speaking
about the need for consistency and rationalisation
in the telecom policy, Mr Tata said that vested
interests were guiding the turbulence in the industry
as people do not want new players in the field.
He spoke of the need to allow full roaming, "though
not on an unfair basis to them (cellular operators)
and ensuring a level playing field".