Business
excellence in the Internet Age
November
24, 2000
CEO
S. Ramadorai addressed the Commonwealth Business
Council at London on November 23, 2000. Following
are the excerpts of his speech at the luncheon.
The Right Honorable the Earl Cairns, and esteemed
colleagues. I am deeply honoured by your invitation
to speak at this prestigious forum, the Commonwealth
Business Council. Thank you for your kindness

We are indeed in the throes of a revolution, the
'Internet revolution', which offers us many opportunities
for growth and prosperity, but also brings in
its wake many potential threats and uncertainties.
The Internet is undermining, and in some cases
threatening, to obliterate many traditional business
structures and models. It is therefore critical
that we all, as business leaders in the Internet
era, revisit our current approach to measuring
business excellence, our topic for the day.
Indian businesses recognise that any engagement
in the areas of finance, banking, insurance, medical
services will require that they are internet-enabled.
Indeed, it was quite gratifying to read a recent
survey in The Economist on this issue, (Frances
Cairncross, "Inside the Machine: A Survey
of E-Management," 11-17 November 2000) with
a perspective that is similar to my own.
It is also exciting to note that the UK industry,
(and the UK Government) are seized of the issue
of moving quickly to take advantage of the rich
opportunities offered by the Internet. Over the
years, the UK government has instituted a series
of policies and initiatives aimed at helping the
growth of electronic commerce. These include the
Information Age Partnership, an initiative with
CEOs of over 35 major IT and e-commerce companies,
to enhance the strategic interface between Government
and e-commerce enabling industries.
It is our understanding that the UK government
has set itself the ambitious goal of "making
the UK the world's best place to trade electronically
by 2002." We are also proud that similar
initiatives are underway in India.
I believe that we are in the 'mature' phase of
the Internet era, a phase for which Evan Schwartz
has aptly coined the term "Digital Darwinism,"
an era of 'survival of the fittest'. In a sense,
the Internet is creating a perfect market scenario
where market participants, unfettered by constraints
of time or space have increasing access to information
with which they can make increasingly informed
choices, while all the world is their playing
ground. At the same time, the Internet brings
these participants face-to-face with the world's
best players where there is little tolerance for
even 'minor' mistakes.
An 'excellent business leader' today will need
to wrestle with several complex questions. I will
cite a few.
- How will the virtuality of organisations affect
their governance?
- What kinds of employment policies will make
'creative destruction' less threatening and yet,
productive?
- How will virtual organisations be structured
to be customer oriented?
- What intellectual assets will they protect from
the public purview, and which of those assets
will they share to enhance their own (and overall)
societal progress?
'Fit' managers and 'fit' corporations will need
many diverse qualities. They will need to be compassionate
and empowering employers, passionate and visionary
entrepreneurs, level-headed decision-makers, democrats
and team players all rolled into one. They will
need to be prompt, full of energy, they will need
clear strategic focus, the ability to dynamically
shift strategies in response to the changing requirements
of creative destruction, a chief characteristic
of skill- and information-intensive industries.
They will need the ability to think on their feet
creatively, immediately, to be able to recognise
competition even as they adapt to "co-opetition."
There is an additional threat to private operators
from India's state-owned monopoly operators. In
several countries, including Australia, the U.K.,
and the USA, clear restrictions were placed on
the activities of the dominant operator, which
often has the market power to drive new players
out of existence through unfair competitive practices.
How can private operators argue that it is against
the national interest to continue to allow state-owned
enterprises to provide cheap telecom services?
It is here that the debate is stalled. The Videsh
Sanchar Nigam Limited and the Mahanagar Telephone
Nigam Limited, both state-owned telecom giants
are positioning themselves to control large chunks
of the Internet market through subsidies.
Excellent managers will need to create 'flat'
organizations, characterized by an open environment,
which encourages creativity, out-of-box thinking,
non-conformance and knowledge-sharing. They will
need to build structures and processes to facilitate
rapid communication and diffusion of ideas, and
effective knowledge capture in an environment
where work-forces are becoming increasingly spread
out geographically, and also becoming more mobile.
For this, excellent managers need to effectively
use IT including email, intranet technologies,
knowledge management tools, etc. HR processes
also need to be made more responsive to the needs
of the Internet-age employee. Organizations have
already started utilizing IT tools such as collaboration
software, Intranet websites, etc, to streamline
HR processes. TCS, for instance, has a repository
of its employees' skill sets, which is easily
accessible to HR managers and which helps them
to match employee skill sets with requirements,
in Internet time.
The Internet is clearly provoking companies to
dynamically restructure their existing infrastructure.
Companies are also redefining their vision or
'reason for existence'. For instance, Microsoft's
earlier 'PC on every desk' has now evolved to
'empowering people through great software anywhere,
on any device.'
I would like to emphasise that we need to embrace
the Internet and maximize its use in everything
we do, whether it is to improve the efficiency
of our internal systems, to gather and disseminate
knowledge, and to communicate with our customers
and our suppliers in the extended enterprise.
In their search for business excellence, managers
will need to use the Internet creatively to reduce
costs, to enhance productivity and to eliminate
fat intermediaries to survive in the face of intensified
competition. New, lean intermediaries, now called
'infomediaries', will emerge to take their place
and to perform specific Internet age activities.
Transaction cost-reductions and the need to improve
productivity will be essential requirements for
survival and to combat intensifying competition.
Excellent business managers will need to critically
differentiate their wealth-creating and wealth-destroying
activities. Business excellence will be measured
in terms of 'wealth-creation'. Companies and individuals
that pursue wealth-destroying activities will
face certain death in the marketplace. Speed,
efficiency, reliability and instant information
will be critical success factors in the new Internet
economy.
When Michael Dell reduces his inventory holding
time to six days, his competitors cannot afford
to hold sixty days' inventory in an industry where
the value of materials declines at about an astounding
'one per cent per week'. Reduced inventory, Dell
claims, has enabled him to achieve a return on
invested capital of two hundred and ninety percent.
If his competitors do not eliminate their inefficiencies,
then they are essentially destroying wealth since
they are operating at a level far below what is
potentially possible.
When a financial services provider reduces the
distribution costs of goods and services - 1 cent
on the internet compared to 25 cents via a cash
machine, 52 cents via the telephone and US$ 1.14
via the bank teller - then its competitors can
hardly afford to ignore such dramatic cost reductions
in response to the scrutiny of their shareholders
and to the competitive demands of the marketplace.
So how does one tailor the Internet to Business
Requirements
The role (and importance) of the Internet and
of 'IT as an enabler' will vary from industry
to industry. Business excellence will depend upon
managers having a clear understanding of the business
they are in, the potential role that technology
can play to enable them to compete effectively
and the impact of the internet on their business
- whether it threatens to destroy their business
or enhance it.
Certain industries which are well-suited to electronic
transactions and electronic delivery of goods
and services such as software, books and music
have already seen seismic shifts. The incumbents,
so to speak, have been forced to drastically restructure
their businesses to survive and achieve competitiveness.
A classic example is the case of Encyclopedia
Britannica. Charles Schwab's business restructuring,
in response to the E*Trade equation, is of the
same genre.
In certain industries the Internet has helped
to dramatically improve business processes and
business efficiency in 'supply chain management
systems' because these businesses deal with the
delivery of standardised goods. In these industries,
overcoming customers' fear of the unknown is easier,
because in the ultimate analysis they can visualise
what will be delivered at their doorsteps. Classic
cases in this segment include Dell, Cisco and
automobile firms.
The third industry-type is the 'hybrid' model
where brick and mortar structures will remain
significant. This model includes financial services
firms where IT plays a crucial role to achieve
business excellence, and where IT is intrinsically
linked with business models. Today, competitive
pressures are forcing banks to undertake initiatives
designed to increase the efficiency of their business
processes. Also, in order to successfully cross-
sell new products and services and achieve the
economies of scale expected as a result of sector
convergence, financial institutions require increasingly
sophisticated IT solutions. These IT solutions
would work towards developing products, managing
customer relationships, mining, managing and analysing
critical customer data and fine-tuning sales and
service delivery operations. They are also utilising
information technology to create new sources of
revenue to deliver new services and products.
From a strategic perspective their approach to
the Internet and IT systems can be expressed in
the following manner. At a lower order level,
banks are using the Internet to achieve operational
effectiveness, something that their competitors
can easily duplicate. In such industries, even
if online delivery is unprofitable for certain
services, it is essential to match competitor
initiatives and consumer demands.
At a higher order level, they are using IT to
position themselves strategically with new products
and services and differentiated services for prime
customers. In their search for excellence, managers
must recognise that utilising technology to pare
down inefficiencies, that is, to achieve operational
effectiveness, only gives them 'the licence to
compete'. It does not give them a sustainable
differentiator. To truly achieve a sustainable
differentiation, firms require a deeply embedded,
complex web of customer-oriented business processes
solidly grounded on IT processes, which in turn,
will be structured into a well designed IT architecture
based on a clear business strategy. Competitors
will find it difficult to replicate this structure
and it will go a long way to enhance customer
retention. These business processes tied together
by a single thread - a single strategy, will include
the whole gamut of corporate activities including
knowledge sharing, research and development activities,
customer-care management, mechanisms for individual
customer valuation, etc.
IT clearly has a critical role to play in ensuring
that this strategic symphony plays out smoothly.
The role of the CIO (or Chief Information Officer)
is also undergoing a transformation in the Internet
and IT driven era. Previously 'support' functions,
CIOs now play a crucial role in defining the enterprise's
strategy, and in overseeing its implementation.
CIOs are permanent members of the business strategy
team. CIOs must have a broad business perspective
and a penchant for change. They must combine the
skills of technocrat and business leader, linking
the present with the future.
Indeed, it is the first time in business history
that the role of the IT manager has become mission
critical for corporate survival. The mantle of
ensuring that the IT architecture, founded on
sound business and IT strategic visioning, with
well thought out and detailed business and IT
processes, works right, every time, rests on the
shoulders of the CIO. CIOs must ensure that the
IT architecture is glitch-free, with the capacity
to respond (with flexibility) to future changes.
Internet time, after all, gives business managers
no room for mistakes. Business and IT processes
must be scaleable to respond to the dynamically
changing marketplace. To be wrong will be suicidal;
to be right will bring great corporate prosperity.
I will cite the example of the Indian private
telecom industry when it was just starting out,
to demonstrate the value of defining business
processes well in advance. The nascent Indian
telecom industry started out with little understanding
of the 'key makers' and 'breakers' of the business.
Consequently, Indian telecom firms climbed a steep
and tortuous learning curve. Without a clear understanding
of customer-oriented tariff packages, some companies
did not institute customer care and billing systems
to cater to "friends and family" type
programs and long-term loyalty programs, essential
for customer retention. Inadequate information
capturing systems and processes prevented companies
from capturing fraudulent behaviour patterns leading
to tremendous losses. An inadequate billing system
can create havoc. Companies were often unable
to raise bills, and obviously, without billing
there can be no revenues.
Management Excellence in the Mature Phase of
the Internet
The 'introduction phase' of the Internet involved
eyeball capture with little attention to robust
revenue models. It was a phase concerned with
"content push" irrespective of quality
under the aegis of the free ISP "eyeball
capture" model.
(Under the "content push" approach,
everything under the sun that the Internet offers
free, is acceptable, irrespective of its quality)
The "content push" culture would, if
it had continued to hold sway, have created a
culture of mediocrity. Furthermore, it is a culture
which puts tremendous pressure on individuals
in terms of "taxing our eyes and brains,"
in an uncertain gamble for information that may
or may not be available and that may or may not
be right and enough despite its vast expanse.
Of course, the true potential of the Internet
is still to be realised. As Michael Dertouzas,
director of the MIT Laboratory for Computer Science
emphasises, we are currently utilising only approximately
one-tenth of the web's full potential. Fortunately,
we are now entering the 'mature phase' of the
evolution of the Internet. We are entering a phase
when the computer and communications systems will
become "human centres" catering to 'human
needs', not vice versa. The Internet's potential
will be realised when our machines speak to us,
and unload work off our backs, in an exacting
and discriminating manner. For this, we need,
intelligent IT systems and software, capable of
organising, structuring, intelligently abandoning
useless knowledge, contextually and building upon
the vast store of data, information and knowledge,
also in context, that is exponentially increasing
by the hour. This can lead to a tremendous innovation
explosion and to increasing certainty in our research
efforts.
Indeed, we can even envisage a period when computers
will increasingly predict when we are pursuing
the wrong research path and the relative risks
and rewards of pursuing it from a commercial and
knowledge building perspective.
'Collaboration' - a key mantra in the Internet
era
The Internet paradigm is all about 'global collaboration.'
Managers striving for excellence will also need
to give due recognition to the new concept of
'co-opetition'. The exigency of competing on 'Internet
time' means that companies must simultaneously
compete and cooperate with each other. We are
witnessing communication, connectivity and partnerships
on a scale as yet, unprecedented. The process
is becoming evident with the obsolescence of the
'vendor-centric' business model and with the opensource
software movement gaining currency. Under the
opensource software model, the software developers
make their software available freely on the Internet
for anybody to make enhancements or develop applications.
Although software developers run the risk of creating
powerful competitors through this model, they
also ensure that the software has a wide support
base of developers and users, thereby ensuring
the 'longevity' of the software product. As you
know, Linux is a classic example.
Another major form of emerging collaboration is
the business model of alliances among competing
firms to spread their risks and their costs. Also,
because technology is becoming obsolete so rapidly,
in several industries, companies have to produce
new and fresh products and services, in increasingly
shorter time periods. Indeed, they must have the
stomach to proactively make obsolete their own
products, applications and solutions. The cost
of research and development is often difficult
to recover. Information-intensive businesses must
use alliances to rapidly access the benefits of
scientific advancements made by other firms, academic
and research institutes and government departments.
It is becoming quite common for companies to share
their plans and products and processes with outside
groups, compared to the earlier tradition of corporate
secrecy. In the new era of the Internet, companies
will pursue collective action and collaborative
efforts in "clusters" as strategic initiatives
to survive and to promote enlightened "self-interest"
instead of pursuing the tunnel-vision path of
only "competing." Indeed, firms are
even using knowledge management tools to determine
which alliances, mergers and acquisitions they
must pursue to provide total solutions. What is
even more amazing is the emergence of models comprising
loose confederations of companies which share,
among other areas, customer acquisition and recruitment
costs.
Convergence
Managers pursuing excellence also need to be fully
cognizant of the all-pervasive computing scenario
that is rapidly emerging. Although we may not
see the demise of the PC in the near future, there
is no disputing the fact that its days, as the
number one device to access the Internet and conduct
transactions, are numbered. A variety of devices
are becoming available which enable an individual
to access the Internet anytime and anywhere. So
instead of having to worry about one type of user
interface for the PC, e-commerce providers will
have to provide multiple user interfaces on a
number of devices.
Software Developers and Consultants
In such a scenario, software companies - both
developers and service providers - have a critical
role to play. After all, software is a critical
element, which keeps the business running in the
electronic market place, and in certain cases,
such as Amazon, is an essential factor for competitive
differentiation.
Software development companies are launching products,
which will enable business managers to achieve
global connectivity through the Internet, and
tailor their solutions to their business models.
These products provide a multitude of functionalities
-simplified development of next-generation web
services, rapid application development for the
internet, 'build and reach' of applications through
any channel, automatic XML integration, creation
and consumption of web services, enterprise-scale
interoperability management, and solutions for
cyber security, etc.
Business managers are being constantly bombarded
with new applications, new products and new solutions
such as componentisation, software as a service,
enterprise-wide application integration, etc.
They need to be able to sift through all the hype
and finalise the best solution. Software consultants
can play a critical role in this respect.
Choosing the right solution and the right consultant
to deploy optimum solutions is mission-critical.
Failure could lead to the loss of competitive
position and market share. In recent times several
companies have suffered considerable pain and
losses because of the service disruptions and
the constraints that resulted from failed or inadequate
deployment of new systems. In the age of digital
solutions and digital business models, companies
can no longer afford six-month studies and twenty-four-month
implementation periods. Further, digital solutions
require a holistic approach combining customer
orientation with cultural, business and technical
issues. It is critical to focus on solutions first
and on technology later. The ability to sell,
conceive and deploy effective digital solutions
requires an understanding of the dynamics of specific
industries and marketplaces. Software consultants
who intend to deliver solutions that truly enhance
and extend traditional business models will require
sales personnel and consultants with substantial
industry expertise.
Managerial excellence for software consultants
and product development requires that they constantly
review the future initiatives of their clients
and incorporate this knowledge into their research
and development, recruitment and training activities.
Indeed, in recent years, many consulting firms
have formed strategic advisory boards to identify
and evaluate future market trends. These boards
comprise technology and industry experts and independent
thought leaders from the academic world. Indeed,
these boards are an illustration of the 'open
partnership model' that is essential for the successful
delivery of digital solutions. Another critical
requirement for successful consultancy in the
Internet era is to establish partnership relationships
with clients. Clients will increasingly require
consultants to enter retainer-based relationships,
taking the responsibility to maintain and enhance
applications, in an era of rapidly shortening
product and solution life cycles.
Building Deep Customer Relationships
The Internet is a 'customer-oriented' medium where
the customer is completely in charge of the interaction
with the firm, relatively free from any pressure
from sales pitches. This forces firms to accept
the reality of all-powerful customers and to become
more responsive to them. Consumers can reject
goods and services through the click of a mouse,
if a firm does not adequately respond to their
queries. Consumers are also better able to compare
goods and services on the net and obtain free
information from competitors. Consequently, firms
have been forced to divulge large amounts of information
about themselves.
On the other hand, the Internet offers rich possibilities
for companies willing to make an effort to understand
their customers and develop a strong relationship
with them. Research has shown that loyalty of
online shoppers is related much more to the customer
experience than to traditional drivers such as
price. The top two drivers of online loyalty are
1. The quality of the customer experience and
2. The on-time delivery. Customer Relationship
Management is already emerging as a distinct domain,
and technologies are being developed specifically
for this. Through 'mining' their customer data
warehouses for nuggets of information and identifying
their most profitable customers, organisations
can devise better ways of selling to existing
customers and appropriately tailor their offerings.
Some companies have gone a step further in building
their customer relationships. General Motors,
for instance, uses OnStar - a geographical positioning
system to locate customers' vehicles, diagnose
engines and even control their vehicle operations
- the next generation in e-CRM.
Externalities & Dependencies
All said and done, business excellence does not
depend ONLY on strong managers and correct corporate
and technology strategies. Political, economic,
regulatory, legal, social and cultural factors
too will significantly determine the extent to
which managers can utilise the Internet effectively.
Governments will play an important role in creating
a legal and policy framework to create an enabling
environment for business managers to exploit the
benefits of IT and the Internet. Unclear taxation
and tariff policies, constitutional, ethical and
legal issues such as security and privacy issues,
and public policies that prevent the growth of
critical telecom infrastructure will serve as
major disablers in the new environment.
Further, whole industries, such as the telecom
industry in particular, have a major responsibility
to create the necessary convergent infrastructure.
Inadequate bandwidth will prevent firms from fully
exploiting the Internet advantage. A critical
mass of users with access to affordable, internet-compatible
devices is essential to utilise this "general
purpose technology" effectively. In the absence
of these enablers, the divide between digital
haves and have-nots will increase. For instance,
in the US, abundant bandwidth and inexpensive
telecom access have played an instrumental role
in rapidly moving the internet economy into the
maturity phase. Although some measures are already
underway in this area, governments and companies
in India and the UK will need to fully embrace
such an approach.
Conclusion
I would like to conclude by saying that we need
to look carefully at all the possible avenues
to exploit the 'Internet-advantage' together,
through win-win partnerships and by enhancing
the use of our complementary strengths. TCS and
other Indian software firms, offer deep multi-disciplinary
skills and capabilities to enable business entities
to identify their long-term business and IT strategies
with well-developed business and IT solutions
to achieve business success.
I thank you once again for giving me this opportunity
to be here, and I am confident that the Commonwealth
Business Council will serve as an incubator, indeed,
as a powerful engine for cooperative and successful
relationships to achieve our common goal of business
excellence in the Internet era.
|
|