It’s
not often that Ratan Tata retreats into the shadows
when the company he steers is buffeted by a barrage
of charges that leave scars of mistrust.
But when the man stepped out today to clear the
air on everything that’s troubled his group in
the past few weeks, he was more than willing to
clasp the hot potatoes. "I’m glad you referred
to Tata Finance Ltd (TFL)," he told shareholder
at VSNL’s annual general meeting.
However, he did show signs of unease at the fact
that there was too much of an attempt to dredge
out dirt. "There is a concerted effort to
get bad news from somewhere," he said in
a statement as loaded as the disputes.
And, then came the flurry of facts and figures
to fortify denials. "No Tata Finance fixed
deposit holder or stakeholder has suffered a loss.
We have pumped a sum of Rs 500-700 crore into
the company. We have put in the money because
it was our moral responsibility."
The Tata chief made a clean breast of the controversies
engulfing his group when he fielded questions
from scribes on the sidelines of the VSNL meeting.
Rebutting imputations made by former TFL managing
director Dilip Pendse, he denied knowledge of
investment decisions taken by Tata Finance, particularly
those of its subsidiary, Niskalp Investments.
Tata claimed he came to know of TFL’s financial
funk in April 2001, from Pendse, who called him
in Dubai to talk about the problem.
"It is absolutely untrue that I was consulted
by Pendse and I was not involved in TFL and its
issues," Tata asserted. "The first time
I was informed was when Pendse called me up in
Dubai in April last year. If I was involved why
would he contact me?" he said. The closing
argument: "All issues will now be settled
in court."
Pendse had put in his papers in February 2001
and relieved in May 2001. He filed an affidavit
on August 16 in the Mumbai high court, arguing
he was not the only one responsible for the string
of losses suffered by TFL and Niskalp. He claimed
the directors on the board of the two companies
were aware of the investments all along.
The Tatas accused Pendse of cheating and criminal
breach of trust, causing a Rs 424-crore loss to
Tata Finance.
On the controversial VSNL board meeting that
cleared the bulge-bracket Rs 1,200-crore investment
in Tata Teleservices, Tata told shareholders:
"I would not like to add to the controversy.
The question of this investment did not require
the approval of the government."
"The general view was that there was no
dissent at the meeting. Still, the government-appointed
nominee on the board was of the view that he had
disagreed. We have recorded his views later,"
he added.