Economic
Times May 17, 2002
TAS
is dead, long live TAS. Once considered the private
sector equivalent of the Indian Administrative
Services (IAS), TAS bit the dust in the nineties.
Corporate Dossier dissects its Second Coming.
On
June 6 this year, a batch of 17 management graduates,
including one from Harvard Business School, will
walk through the doors of the Tata Management
Training Centre in Pune to start its tryst with
Tata Administrative Service (TAS). These 20-somethings
are certainly not the first to do so, nor are
they likely to be the last. Why, then, do they
matter? Because they’re walking in at a time when
TAS is making a conscious effort to break from
the past, and reinvent itself to meet the needs
of the changing times.
Given its relevance to the development of a leadership
pipeline, TAS is being given a makeover. Says
Satish Pradhan, executive vice president, group
human resources, Tata Sons: "It’s about growing
tigers. You cannot grow tigers in your backyard,
you need a jungle to grow them. TAS provides that
space, and scope. It’s vital to sourcing talent
for the group." It’s almost as if ‘discontinuity’
has become a need at what’s perhaps the only cadre
of its sort in the private sector, grooming talent
for a career of life-long mobility across industries
and functions.
Once considered the private sector equivalent
of the IAS, it’s going out of its way to shed
that similarity by doing away with the ‘misnomer’
Tata Administrative Services. From now on, it’s
going to call itself TAS, much like International
Business Machine calls itself IBM. A significant
break from the past has been the decision to shut
its doors on non-management graduates. All 17
recruits this year are management school products.
The ‘eclectic recruiter’ who welcomed people from
all streams will now recruit only from the best
B-schools in the country.
Explains Allen Sequeira, vice president, group
resourcing and TAS: "We do not have the luxury
of grooming talent from scratch as we used to
in the past. We’re a business and times demand
that we hire management graduates who come with
a certain level of understanding about the ways
of business." Following its chairman’s ‘back-to-basics’
philosophy, TAS too is concentrating on what it’s
best at — grooming the best and the brightest
from A-rated campuses who have already passed
through the stringent admission procedures of
top business schools.
Aggression is the new order at TAS — nothing but
Day One status will be acceptable while visiting
campuses for recruitment. It’s competing with
the Accentures, Citibanks, GE Caps and HLLs of
the world for the same talent at the creme de
la creme of management schools. It’s also differentiating
itself in the crowded placement market. When it
went to B-schools this year, it preferred not
to follow the Power Point presentation routine.
Says a TAS recruit of 2002: "They branded
their talk in a very un-PPTish way, and made it
very exciting by combining it with off-campus
activities." For the uninitiated, PPT stands
for pre-placement talk by companies at B-school
campuses. TAS conducted market research on campuses
across the country last year, and then followed
it up with a series of initiatives to talk about
the group. Not only was a ‘Tata Business Leadership
Awards’ contest conducted on various campuses,
an old Harvard case study on the Tatas was dug
out for circulation on campuses.
R Gopalakrishnan, executive director of Tata Sons
and a member of the Group Executive Office, was
asked to teach the Tata case study at a few campuses.
Says Pradhan: "By moving in to the premium
status in B-school campuses, we’ve reclaimed the
status lost in the last few years." Of course,
the downturn in the job market has helped. TAS
competes directly with consulting firms because
of its general management career path. Given that
not too many consulting firms were in a hiring
mode this year — after the spate of layoffs announced
last year — TAS moved up the preference list fairly
effortlessly.
It’s also become more competitive in terms of
salaries. Says a Tata manager who graduated from
a B-school in 2000: "Salaries were a major
part of why TAS lost out when the MNCs came in;
the pay was incomparable and acted as a discouraging
factor." Current recruits have been offered
a salary of Rs 6 lakh per annum, which is pretty
competitive with the average Indian salaries of
Rs 5.5-6.5 lakh on various B-school campuses this
year.
The selection procedure itself is being given
a technical shot in the arm to make it more robust.
The recruits this year had to undertake IRIS,
a new tool with scientific determinants to gauge
a candidate’s capabilities with respect to the
six ‘work levels’ or layers of management, being
followed internally by the group. The group heavyweights
who sat through group discussions were given a
set of Tata leadership practices, and a guide
on how to recognise those in an interviewee.
It’s also going to be more proactive in future.
Unlike in the past, when projects were decided
once the TAS recruits arrived at a certain company,
a rigorous 12-month schedule is being drawn up
for them. To start with, there will be a gruelling
routine while undergoing a 3-5 weeks of classroom
training at TMTC, Pune. The legendary ‘Bharat
Darshan’ tour of Tata companies is also being
put to use. The cosmetic change is that it’s being
renamed ‘group induction tour.’
The actual change from past is that recruits will
have to make a presentation on what they saw and
how they understood it after they come back from
a two- or three-week tour of various Tata companies
like Tata Tea plantations in Assam and the Jamshedpur
steel plants. And that’s not all that is being
demanded from recruits. Unlike in the past, just
getting recruited will not be enough. A performance
evaluation at the end of the 12-month training
programme will decide whether the recruit will
be confirmed or not.
Also, of the four assignments that cadre recruits
will work on, one will have to be in community
space, and will involve living in a village for
at least a week. Shades of Hindustan Lever, did
you say? These efforts seem to be paying off,
though it’s early days yet. Of the total batch
strength of 1,395 in the top nine institutes,
around 951 applied to TAS. Moreover, 17 of the
20 offers made by the Tata group were accepted.
Those who made it had grade point averages in
the top end of their batch. Says Sriram Chandrasekharan,
manager, TAS: "In the last two years, the
number of IIM graduates joining us has increased
substantially."
This in itself is a big change from the past.
Says a graduate who’s joining TAS this year, "They
had a severe image trouble on campuses in the
last five years. They were too fuddy-duddy."
Unfortunately, this was also the time when foreign
firms in India and abroad were coming live on
those campuses. As a result, TAS failed to find
its place in post-liberalisation India. There
was simply too much baggage associated with it:
unglamorous, laid-back and unfocused being some
of them. Moreover, a ‘life-time employer’ was
no longer an attractive option for life in the
fast lane.
Not that TAS itself did much to improve its image.
Says Jamshed Daboo, a TAS recruit from 1986 and
COO, Indian Hotels, a rising star at the Tata
group: "TAS has never been a vacancy-filling
job. Since there was no magnet of demand, it did
not market itself to suppliers. So if anything,
it’s the marketing of TAS that failed it in the
past few years." Even within the Tata group,
TAS was losing its aura. The entry of professionals
like Gopalakrishnan at the top tier of management
within the group in a way reflected that TAS had
lost out on providing leaders for the group. Sequeira
clarifies: "Of the 120-odd TAS recruits at
present, about 17-18 are CEOs of group companies."
There’s a view that with the entry of some top
management professionals from Hindustan Lever,
the recruitment and training procedure is borrowed
in bits and pieces from the most admired multinational
in the country. Pradhan denies any similarity
between the new TAS and traditional management
trainee programmes run by companies like HLL.
"TAS recruits work across at least four Tata
companies — if not four industries and four functions
— in their first year itself. Which other company
can offer a training programme like this?"
he counters.
All said and done, the death of the TAS of yesteryear
is also a sad occasion for old-timers, for whom
the tag was a life-long value addition to their
résumé. The new TAS resembles any other training
program followed by a GE or an HLL, in spirit
at least. That’s very different from the institution
that Tata Administrative Services was — sourcing
multi-disciplinary talent and grooming it in its
backyard. The old order changeth...