Times
of India August 31, 2001
Mumbai:
Bombay
House officials liken the group’s foray into every
telecom segment as a flotilla of ships, moving
in concert and based on a plan. Switch the navy
whites for the cricketing sort and the metaphor
still works. Bombay House (or rather the Group
Executive Office headed by Ratan Tata) is the
captain who will assign the roles which the players
will carry out. The selectors of the team are
group companies like Tata Power, Tata Steel and
Tata Industries, which will invest the funds to
make the infocom plays work.
Extending
the analogy, the players will have different roles.
The Sachinesque-rock around which the team will
play is a new, yet nameless firm with an initial
equity of Rs.700 crore to be formed by three Tata
companies to house the Groups’ customer-interfacing
communications businesses like basic telephony
and ISP services.
Tata
Power’s Broadband Division with more than 200
kilometres of lit optic fibre in and around Mumbai
is the outfielder. In the gullies Tata Internet
with its data and ISP services. Tata Teleservices
will cover a part of the field with basic services
in Andhra Pradesh, while the Batata-BPL combine
is ready to catch any cellular calls in the air.
On the sidelines stand Tata Consultancy Services,
a 12th man like Bradman’s Wally Hammond,
with 3,000 telecom engineers and a Rs.600 crore
telecom business, ready to come to the aid of
each player, be it for building an integrating
networks or common billing systems.
A
formidable team, but is it good enough to redefine
this smokestacks and engineering group by its
infocom and other service businesses in the 21st
century, just as it was by textiles in the 19th
and steel in the 20th ? Is the captain-in
this case, the GEO headed by Ratan Tata good enough
to win the match?
The
captain’s or GEO's telecom strategy is complex
because Team Tata has no idea whether the pitch
will turn on the fourth day i.e. what technology
will suceed in India in the future, or whether
the umpires will be impartial in terms of the
regulatory environment. Thus, unlike other groups
like Reliance, which has placed its bets on wire-less-in-local-loop
(WLL) technology, or Hutchison, which has placed
its bets on the cellular field. Team Tata is keeping
its options intact by maintaining its presence
in all the different telecom domains. This will
help them capture value at different points of,
say, a phone call, depending on the prevalent
tariff and regulatory regime. The basic idea?
Once you have hold on a customer, try and capture
all the value within the group.
Even
more interesting for corporate observers is whether
the Tatas can play as a team at all. Historically,
the Tatas have been a loose federated structure
with the centre not dictating to the group companies.
"The Tatas founded a company, appointed a
CEO and the company did its own thing-its off-spring
may fight with one another, but the Tata patriarch
felt that they were adults and should make their
own decisions," says a Tata watcher. In other
words, the Tata companies were procreating randomly.
In this scenario, collaborations within the group
were more emotive, based on individual contacts,
rather than rational or institutionalised.
The
captain’s table
That may now be changing. The infocom initiative
is the most visible sign, the first time that
the group is invading a business on the basis
of a centrally crafted strategy with specific
roles being assigned to group companies. But this
new spirit of co-operation, fostered through forums
like Group Management Meets, is being extended
to buying each other’s goods, from telephones
to tea, negotiating as one entity for outside
goods and services and following Bombay House’s
initiatives on human resources and work levels.
For
better or worse, this new structure has brought
about other, less visible changes. The board of
Tata Sons, for instance, is no longer filled with
statesmen and ambassadors like Nani Palkhivala,
but with hard-nosed professionals like R.Gopalakrishnan
and Ishaat Hussain, who think nothing of making
marketing calls to bag deals for TCS.
Even
the average age of a Tata Son’s board member has
fallen to 66 from 69 years in the last five years.
Moreover, under a GEO structure, CEOs can no longer
expect lifelong employment in a company and must
be ready to move around the group. At least ten
CEOs of the group have been changed in the last
four years, including companies like Tata Steel,
Indian Hotels and Voltas.
If
successful, the infocom business will also remake
the Tata group’s image from a metals and chimneys
group making steel to a services company associated
mainly with wires and routers. R.Gopalakrishnan,
executive director of Tata Sons and a GEO member,
predicts that more than 75 percent of the group’s
revenues will come from branded goods and services
by 2010. Currently, more than 40 per cent of the
group’s sales of Rs.35,000 crore come from services
whereas commodities counted for more than 80 per
cent a decade ago.