The
New Raj at Tata
Business Week November 27, 1997
Its chairman lights a fire under
the lumbering group
Shareholders of Indian Hotels Co. have always known
that the company's corporate parent was the Tata group,
the Bombay-based conglomerate that has the best-known
name in Indian business. However, Tata's influence on
the hotel operator had always seemed remote - until
the annual meeting of Indian Hotels in October. Instead
of chatting cozily over tea with longtime chief Ajit
Kerkar, investors found themselves in the stern presence
of Ratan N. Tata himself, chairman of Tata Sons. Just
weeks before, Tata also became chairman of the hotel
company-and then forced Kerkar into retirement. At the
meeting, Tata told shareholders how much he now had
to do to get the hotel chain in shape.
Many of the shareholders were
amazed: They didn't really think that the hotels needed
fixing. However, Ratan Tata doesn't just want to upgrade
the hotels. The new chairman has a far bigger ambition:
to rein in the executives who run the Tata companies
like independent fiefdoms, impose some strategic direction
on his sprawling empire of 84 companies, increase the
shareholding of the Tata clan in these companies - and
enormously enhance his own position.Seen in that light,
Ratan Tata's moves at Indian Hotels are just skirmishes
in a much bigger battle to impose the largest restructuring
ever on the 140-year-old group, which has some $10 billion
in annual sales. And deposing the popular Kerkar is
a signal to the other chiefs that at Tata, it's no longer
business as usual.
Sleepy stock:
Whether Ratan, now 59 and in his sixth year as chairman,
can pull all this off is unclear. But in a rare interview,
Ratan Tata argues that with increasing competition and
globalization, his companies must change now or risk
becoming also-rans. "I'd like it to be a coherent
group that's within the first three in any of the business
we are in India," he says. He also thinks that
the foreign institutional investors now looking at the
shares of Indian companies want a lot more clarity from
Indian management before making a big commitment.
Shares of a number of Tata companies,
in fact, have lagged the over all Indian stock market,
even though the best-known have turned in respectable
profits (table). While Tata stocks are considered risk-free
investments, many mutual-fund managers and foreign investors
don't see much potential for big gains. Fund managers
say that many of Tata's businesses are too mature and
in highly cyclical sectors. Investors also want the
group to play more to its strengths. "just a handful
of the 84 companies account for the bulk of (sales),
and Tata needs to focus on those," says Bharat
Shah, chief investment officer of Birla Capital Asset
Management. Shah thinks that the conglomerate should
be pushing its excellent software business, for example,
before Indian rivals catch up with them.
Certainly, focus is what the
Tata companies lack. The group's business include steel,
trucks, energy, air conditioners, fertilizers, paint,
cosmetics, yarn, tea, hotels, software and consumer
finance. Many of the smaller companies, such as Tata
Special Steels and air-conditioner maker Voltas, are
lackluster performers. Although Ratan Tata technically
controls all of these concerns through the holding company
of Tata Sons Ltd., his family's stock holding in Tata
Sons is actually only 3percent or so.
Because of that slender stock
position, Ratan has had to rely mostly on family prestige
as the source of his authority. However, that approach
could get more difficult soon, since India's securities
laws will soon make takeovers easier and the Tata companies
could become targets. Ratan Tata himself could become
vulnerable to ouster by the group's largest, but so
far passive, shareholder, construction magnate Pallonji
S. Mistry, who has bought up 17percent of Tata Sons.
If Ratan Tata is unable to make a success of his restructuring,
business circles whisper that Mistry could install himself
as head of the Tata group. Neither Mistry nor Tata would
comment on this idea.
With such an urgent agenda, Ratan
Tata is working at top speed to consolidate his position
and his empire. In a controversial plan, an $85 million
rights offering in 1995 raised funds to help Tata Sons
acquire more shares in group companies where its stake
was low. Ratan Tata is forcing a number of top executives
at the companies to retire at 65, then putting in his
choices as managing director-while naming himself chairman.
Corporate sources also say consultants McKinsey and
Co. have advised a major reorganization of the group
into more focused industrial, consumer and technology
divisions, with the smaller Tata companies perhaps going
by the board. BIG Gamble. Although Ratan Tata confirms
that he has retained McKinsey, he won't comment on the
report. Yet he is clearly building up the key parts
of his empire. At Tata Iron and Steel, he is spending
almost $3 billion to overhaul steel operations and cut
labour costs. Titan Industries Ltd., a watchmaker in
the group, has invested more than $30 million to make
a splashy foray into Europe. At its 154-hectare plant
in Pune outside Bombay, truckmaker Tata Engineering
and Locomotive is producing India's first indigenous
small car, the Indica, to compete with the Maruti, a
car made locally by Suzuki in a joint venture with the
government. Many auto analysts are skeptical of the
India's success, since Tata will have to face off against
Suzuki as well as Ford, General Motors, Hyundai and
Daewoo. Ratan Tata has staked his reputation on it,
however and gives the $470 million project much of his
time.
Opinion varies on Ratan Tata's
bold moves. Corporate historian Gita Piramal, who has
researched the Tata family and companies, says that
Tata is showing a clarity of thought that has not been
evident in the group for some time. Others feel that
Tata is getting rid of his best managers unnecessarily-and
not grooming the next generation of executives to take
over. Some Tata shareholders are also annoyed with Tata's
plan to charge companies a fee for using the Tata brand
name. Others point out that the intensely private Ratan
lacks the charisma of JRD Tata, his predecessor and
uncle. That's a potentially serious flaw, since Ratan
will have to persuade shareholders and managers to sign
on to his new vision of the company. But for now, Ratan
Tata still has the authority to remake the companies
that bear his name. As Indian business changes, it may
be his last chance.
|
|
1996
Sales millions
|
1996
Profits millions
|
| Tata Engineering |
$2,500
|
$211
|
| Tata Iron and Steel |
1,600
|
130
|
| Tata Chemicals |
471
|
84
|
| Tata Tea |
191
|
16
|
| Indian Hotels |
170
|
41
|
| Titan Industries |
117
|
7
|
Change in stock price since
Jan 3, 1997
|
Companies
|
In per cent
|
| Tata Engineering |
-6
|
| Tata Iron and Steel |
-13
|
| Tata Chemicals |
-23
|
| Tata Tea |
73
|
| Indian Hotels |
-16
|
| Titan Industries |
-17
|
Data HSBC Batlivala and Karani,
Bloomberg Financial Markets.
One intended audience for the ambitious restructuring:
Foreign fund managers.
|
|